Tips for Cheesecake Water Baths
What is a water bath?
A water bath is a method for gently baking a cheesecake in its pan inside another pan filled with boiling water in the oven. It’s also called a bain marie. It’s used for a lot of custard preparations, such as flan and crème brulee. Cheesecake is essentially a custard (not a cake!) since it’s so rich with dairy and eggs.
Why is it so important to bake cheesecake in a water bath?
The number one key to perfectly smooth, luscious, and creamy cheesecake that bakes evenly and without cracks? Low and gentle heat!
A water bath is the best way to ensure that kind of baking environment. Even when you set your oven to 325° to bake a cheesecake, the temperature inside the water bath generally won’t exceed 200°F.
This low and gentle heat evens out the baking so that the outside of the cheesecake doesn’t become tough, rubbery, burnt, or curdled before the inside can finish baking.
You can achieve a similar effect by baking for a long time at a really low oven temperature, but who has the time for that? Additionally, older ovens aren’t reliable at maintaining an accurately low temperature.
A water bath is truly the best way to bake a flawless cheesecake. Just take a look below at what a difference a water bath makes.
Cheesecake water bath vs. cheesecake without water bath:
When you need a cheesecake water bath:
Any full-size cheesecake recipe. Especially classic cheesecake, or any recipe when you really don’t want cracks.
When you don’t need a water bath:
You don’t need one for cheesecake bars, mini cheesecakes, and of course no-bake cheesecake recipes. Bars and mini cheesecakes are thinner than a normal cheesecake, so they cook more evenly.
How to bake in a water bath when the recipe doesn’t call for one:
If the recipe doesn’t call for a water bath, you don’t need to use one.
However, if you want all of the amazing benefits listed above, then simply prepare the water bath as directed down below. Since the water bath cooks more gently, you’ll likely need to increase the baking time. Generally you can bake at 325°F for about 1 hour 15 minutes, depending on the volume of cheesecake batter.
What you need for a water bath:
- A high-quality springform pan
Even the best springform pans aren’t truly “leakproof,” no matter what their packaging claims. However, it’s important to have one that’s heavy duty and high quality for durability and to avoid rusting.
- Larger baking pan, cake pan, sauté pan, or roasting pan
This is the water bath pan so it must fit the springform pan inside. You can also place a large disposable foil pan on top of a rimmed sheet pan for the water bath. Ideally you want something that’s just a couple inches larger than the springform pan.
If you don’t have a pan big enough, I’ve listed some alternative options at the bottom of this article. Just note they won’t be quite as good as a true water bath.
- Wide heavy duty aluminum foil
This helps prevent leaks as you’ll see below. I usually buy this from Costco. It’s important for it to be wider than the diameter of the springform pan so water doesn’t seep through the seams and cracks of the foil.
- Heat safe oven bag or slow cooker bag
This is an optional bonus. Wrapping the springform pan in a heat safe oven bag really helps ensure no water seeps in! Much more foolproof than foil. I like to use BOTH to truly seal off the water.
- Boiling water
A kettle with a spout is the best way to quickly boil water and safely pour it into the roasting pan without splashing any in the cheesecake batter.
How to prevent a water bath from leaking?
Using a high quality springform pan, wide heavy duty aluminum foil, and an oven bag is the best way to all but guarantee you won’t have any leaks!
Alternatives for cheesecake water bath:
1. Low heat & slow baking time
Since the effect of the water bath is to cook the cheesecake custard filling slowly and gently, an easy alternative is to bake the cheesecake without the water bath but in a 275°F for 1 hour 45 minutes. This technique can be a bit tricky and not always a guarantee against cracks if your oven is older, as shown in the comparison below:
On the left is my Classic Cheesecake recipe baked with a water bath. No cracks. On the right is my Pumpkin Cheesecake recipe baked low and slow. You can see a crack still formed. What’s interesting is when I use this method in my home oven with my less than 5 year old electric oven, the crack is usually pretty minimal.
However, when I used this method at my photographer’s house with her older oven the crack was more pronounced. So if your oven is old and doesn’t maintain a low temperature consistently and accurately, this may not be the best method for you. However, if you have a newer or more accurate oven then this may be perfect for you!
This is perfect for those of you who don’t have a large enough pan to act as the water bath vehicle. OR, if you don’t have heavy duty aluminum foil or oven bags and are worried about water leaking in.
Simply place a tray of boiling hot water on the bottom rack of your oven, beneath the middle rack where your springform pan bakes.
Even though you’re not baking the springform pan directly in water with this method, it’s still a good idea to wrap the pan in foil to help shield it from the oven’s heat. You can even use insulated cake strips to protect it!
Could you share what you think are the best springform pans and foil (brand wise)?
Hi Nicki! Here’s the springform pan Tessa uses, which is also linked above in the pink tip box above. She uses wider heavy-duty foil, like this Reynolds foil here. Also, an oven-safe oven/slow-cooker bag will further help prevent leakage – like this one. I hope this helps! Happy baking 🙂
The best way ever!
Thank you for these tips. I do however have a question have you ever baked more than one cheesecake at a time?
I was wondering if it would be possible to put two cheesecakes on the top rack and a water bath on the bottom rack.
Hi Lori! We have not tried baking two cheesecakes at once. I would worry that this would make it difficult for the air to circulate properly in the oven, preventing an even bake – but of course, feel free to experiment and let us know how it goes if you give that a try!
Good day,
Just a quick question. Whats better top and bottom heat or circulating air ? 325 F is that 160 Grad ?
Best regards Ulf
Hi Ulf! It depends on what you’re baking when choosing convection vs. conventional baking methods (more information in Tessa’s article on ovens here). Specifically regarding cheesecake, conventional is best, to avoid the air blowing around the cheesecake too much and hopefully ensure a perfect cheesecake. If your oven has the ability to bake from either the bottom or top using conventional cooking, the heat from the bottom is best with cheesecake, to ensure the top doesn’t overbrown. If it’s top and bottom, watch your cheesecake closely and tent loosely with foil if browning starts to occur. The most important thing with any baking is to ensure your oven rack is positioned in the middle of the oven, to ensure your baked goods aren’t too close to the heat source, and to allow an even distribution of browning. I hope this helps, and I hope you’ll give one of Tessa’s delicious cheesecake recipes a try! Happy baking 🙂
Hi there, I don’t have another cake pan that I can put my springform cake pan into, so I have been wrapping it in 2 layers of foil and placing it directly into a roasting tray with some water. I do notice cracks appear in my cheesecake, but it stays dry. I’m not leaving the cheesecake to cool down in the oven with the door open, though. What do you think could be the cause of the cracks and is the method of using a roasting tray as the Bain Marie ok?
Hi Sharan! It sounds like your method is just fine, especially if your cheesecake is staying dry! I think your cheesecake cracks are due to your lack of cooling it inside the oven slowly, as you suspect. Try sticking a wooden spoon in the oven door to prop it open, leaving it inside the off oven for an hour or so, and then at room temperature for a few hours or until completely cool, before placing in the fridge overnight. Once completely and thoroughly chilled, then remove the springform. This should help your cheesecake stay beautiful and crack-free. Also, be sure you’re not overmixing once your eggs are added, as this can also create cracks. I hope that helps! Happy baking 🙂
Can you make a cheesecake in a regular pan?
Hi Joy! Generally, cheesecake is made in a springform pan for easy removal of the cheesecake from the pan. You could use a regular pan (as long as it’s the same size as the springform pan listed in the recipe), but it won’t come out as cleanly or look as pretty. We recommend using parchment paper with tabs like these, so you can more easily remove your well-chilled cheesecake from the pan. I hope that helps! Happy baking 🙂
I agree with you COMPLETELY that water bath baking is THE BEST way to make a cheesecake. I too have had those ugly surface cracks occur, then it has to be be topped with fruit or something to cover it up. May I suggest forgetting about wrapping in tin foil and oven bags and just use an Easy Bath Cheesecake Wrap- silicone springform pan protector that will not allow water into the springform pan. Period, end of story!
I’m out of town for a month and my
son in law asked me to make a cheesecake.
I went straight to Handle the Heat
( of course!)
I have NEVER MADE such a perfect cheesecake . I used the water bath method which was easy and in the end was beautiful.
The cake tasted so creamy and the best cheesecake ever!
We are honored you came here first, Karen! So glad the cheesecake turned out so perfect 🙂
What temperature and how long do I bake when I mix cake batter with cheesecake batter?
It worked!!, I followed your instructions to a tee. My cheesecake recipe has 8 ounces more of cream cheese. It required more baking time. No cracks!! Thank you!
So glad to hear this worked for you, Lisa!!
When I make a cheesecake, I never prebake the graham cracker crust. I press the graham cracker crust into the pan and fill with the cheesecake mixture and bake. Won’t the graham cracker crust be overcooked ?
Hi Lisa! It does not get overcooked in our experience, but feel free to skip that if you prefer! Happy baking 🙂
Hi
My oven is a gas conventional oven which have 2 racks only, fire on top & bottom.
If i choose to put another pan with water in rack under cheesecake pan, it mean i must put the cheesecake pan in top rack which close to the fire. The space between fire & rack is very close less than 15 centimeters.
Which fire should i use to bake? Top & bottom?
Could you suggest where can i get the oven heat bag please? Any link of your preference bag? Itsnot available in my country.
Thanks
Hi Ashlee! Just to clarify – the foil-wrapped cheesecake pan goes inside the bag, and all of that goes inside the water bath, so the cheesecake bakes sitting inside the water bath. The foil and bag are there to protect the cheesecake from getting wet while it bakes inside the water bath. I hope that makes sense! I would recommend baking on the bottom rack, if the top is very close to the heating element, and also I would recommend dropping the temperature a little, because convection ovens tend to bake a little higher than regular ovens. Also, here is a link to the bags we are referring to. Please reach out if any of this doesn’t make sense! Good luck 🙂
Hi I tried this method and really surrounded the pan with foil. I didn’t use a roasting bag.
The cheesecake turned out great but the base was soggy . Can’t understand why as it was sealed really well
Hi Lavisha! I wish we could have been there baking along with you so I could say for sure, but is it possible your foil may have gotten punctured? How was the top of your cheesecake, did you notice any large, watery bubbles appearing on the surface or edges while it baked? Also, which way did you pre-bake your crust (baked as directed then wrapped in foil or wrapped the pan in foil prior to baking)?
Hi — thanks for this helpful recipe! I misread the directions and put the oven bag around the springform pan first, and then did the foil. My cheesecake came out perfectly, with no cracks, so no complaints at all.. But there was a lot of liquid in the oven bag. It looked like water rather than leaked batter. Either way, the liquid didn’t get to the crust. But is it likely that the bag wouldn’t have filled with liquid if I’d done it right and used the foil and THEN the oven bag?
Hi David! Hmmm…If I’m reading this correctly, it sounds like there may have been a rip or hole somewhere in your foil/bag. The foil and bag should completely prevent any water from not only reaching the springform pan, but they also shouldn’t fill with water themselves. Reversing and having the bag on the outside will help any leaks as long as there are no holes 🙂 Please let me know if I misunderstood your question. I’m so glad your cheesecake still turned out perfectly!
Do you have a recommendation for a pan for the water bath (the large roasting pan, not the springform pan). Thanks!
Hi Liz! We actually don’t have a specific recommendation for a large pan to use as it can literally be anything! Tessa has used her largest skillet or giant square cake pan (wedding cake size) if that helps 🙂
Hi Tessa
I would like to ask you something, if I have to bake 4 cheesecakes a day in a gas convection pastry oven, can you imagine all the work involved in having to line each pan with aluminum foil, and fill the oven with baking trays with
hot water, and the cost that this has?
Or is it that the water bath process only applies to home ovens?
Hi Luis! Water baths aren’t just for home ovens. The only alternative since you’re using a pro oven is to simply bake at a super low temperature for a longer period of time, but you’ll have to experiment with that.
If I am not using a springform pan, but a normal pan, should I wrap it with aluminum foil as well?
You shouldn’t need to with a normal pan. Springform pans have quite a few areas that water can leak into, unlike a regular pan 🙂 I’d highly recommend getting a springform pan for cheesecake though! It makes it so much easier to slice and serve, reducing the stress of breaking/damaging the cheesecake in the process.
I do own a springform pan. But it is 9 inch wide and I own a portable oven, that holds only a maximum of 10 inch wide dish. So trying to figure out how to fit everything in for a water bath. Thanks for the reply. Love your recipes, especially the lemon pound loaf cake. Greetings from India !
You could always try the suggested alternative of placing a tray of water on the bottom oven rack beneath the springform pan if that would be possible! Good luck! And thank you so much for your kind comment, I’m so happy to hear you love my recipes-I agree, the lemon pound cake is SO GOOD! 🙂
What kind of springform pan do you recommend? I’ve taken your advice on your cookie sheets & now I’ve gotta buy a new springform pan. Thanks
This one! Enjoy! https://rstyle.me/+oZK4A0VL7IuwkNNUbY7KJw